Exterior of Costco Wholesale


Ranking Costco's Frozen Desserts From Worst To Best
12. Frozen Cream Puffs
Frozen choux pastries are not that great, and the Delizza frozen cream puffs are not an exception. Reddit reviewers give them a 7 out of 10.
The cream puffs are made with cane sugar, but given their dubious history (they were recalled in 2021 for containing pieces of metal), we decided to pass on them.
11. Nestlé Variety
Costco offers a 40-count variety pack of Nestlé’s vanilla sandwiches, drumsticks, and cookie-dipped bars. We found a few issues with this product.
None of the three items included are technically ice cream, and people don’t find them all that great. There have also been many complaints about quality control regarding packing.
10. Organic Fudge Bars
The Healthy Choice organic fudge bars contain 110 calories, 12 grams of sugar, and some protein and calcium in each bar. However, the execution is subpar.
The problem isn't the bar itself, which Reddit claims tastes like chocolate soft serve. The problem is the icy layer coating them, which makes them physically difficult to eat.
9. JonnyPops
JonnyPops organic watermelon popsicles are vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, kosher, nut-free, and sweetened with cane sugar. However, shoppers are divided on the taste.
TikTok account Costcobffs mentioned that they were overly sweet, and others agreed, noting the "watered down" taste. But some on Reddit disagreed, finding them to be delicious.
8. Ice Cream Bars
The Kirkland Signature chocolate almond-dipped ice cream bars, while fine, do not hold a candle to the Häagen-Dazs ice cream bars they seem to emulate.
Many customers liked the bars but did not find the quality up to par. One Redditor says that the vanilla ice cream was less flavorful, and the chocolate was thick and extra sweet.