Last year, when Redditors turned their attention to Costco’s key lime pie, user ieatoatmeal exclaimed, "I ate an entire one by myself a few years back, but I haven't been able to find it the past 2 years." However, it no longer needs to be a distant fan memory, because Costco has brought back this Kirkland Signature Key Lime Pie and Instagram is loving it.

Costco brought back the oversized pie that weighs a whopping 68 ounces, or 4.25 pounds, just in time for the Fourth of July celebrations. Instagrammer Costco Buys shared a video of the pie and noted that this tangy dessert has a buttery graham cracker crust and sells for $15.99 at their location.

While one pie enthusiast declared that “this is how we eat our feelings,” others lamented that Costco should have a smaller version of the pie, adding “I really wish Costco would do 1/2 pies. We are not a large family and it would be wasteful to buy one." However, the community had a solution ready: eat half and freeze the rest.