Angry at the wine quality, one user commented, “The quality of those wines suck, [...] Costco should be ashamed to sell them,” while another “found one wine out of the [24] that [they] would buy again.” However, one Redditor was surprised by “all the hate it’s getting” since they enjoyed the 2021 selection, and even Buzzfeed noted that at around $4/ bottle, the wines were good value.