The Best Sandwiches Ever Seen On Man V. Food

The sandwich horrors encountered by Adam Richman and, later, Casey Webb on "Man v. Food" are not what the Earl of Sandwich envisioned when he supposedly invented the sandwich. There is no way the sandwich's folkloric namesake thought this was where things were headed. Yet, here we are, getting short of breath while trying to eat a three-foot sub by our lonesome.

Since the show launched in 2008, Richman and Webb have encountered some impossibly gigantic sandwiches. These are sandwiches that can be described equally for their ability to horrify and delight. Though, not every sandwich looks like The Commish, a 5-pound monster Webb encountered at Jake's Deli in Milwaukee. (The Commish features an entire loaf of rye bread and a half-pound of sauerkraut, among plenty of other toppings.) Many sandwiches are more reasonably sized and don't require diners to sign a waiver.

Despite the monstrous portions featured in challenges on "Man v. Food," other sandwiches are deeply alluring bucket list kinds of meals. Here is a look at the most delectable sandwiches from the show.

At Rutgers University, you could once find a row of "grease trucks" that graced the campus for many years. Things have changed in the years since "Man v. Food" visited, though. Nonetheless, at that time, R U HUNGRY? and its famous Fat Sandwiches were a primary attraction among those trucks.  

The hoagies weigh roughly a pound and a half, so it is almost a challenge just to eat one. The actual challenge asks the bold to eat five Fat Sandwiches in 45 minutes. Whether or not diners accept the challenge, the Fat Sandwich comes on a flaky hoagie roll with customizable options that include the option of adding greasy spoon staples like eggs or mozzarella sticks. No matter how it is constructed, it comes topped with a handful of fries.

If a competitor conquers the challenge, they get to make up their own distinct fat sandwich that gets placed on the menu, according to the show. The grease trucks may be gone at Rutgers, but R U Hungry? has opened a couple of restaurants, including one in Newark, New Jersey, to ensure that the legend of Fat Sandwiches lives on.

There may not be a more iconic deli in the United States than Katz's Delicatessen. Even if you've never been, you'd probably recognize it from the famous "When Harry Met Sally" scene. The hype around the deli that opened in 1888 exists for a reason. The food is just as iconic as the reputation. When "Man v. Food" rolled into Katz's, the show focused on that beloved corned beef and pastrami.

This mighty sandwich hits the plate fresh and simple because the ingredients speak for themselves. Most importantly, the meats — the star of this sandwich show — are smoked in-house for three days. The pickles, piled to the side of every sandwich, are also made in-house. The meat is so tender it can make your mouth water right through the screen.

Richman's stop at the deli was not a challenge, so there was never any doubt that he'd finish this classic sandwich piled high with meat.

This side of bread, cheese is arguably the most essential sandwich ingredient in the U.S. With all of the excess on display in "Man v. Food," of course, there is a sandwich that tests the limits of our collective love of cheese.

Melt Bar & Grilled's 5 pound behemoth is a true challenge. At the time of the show, the Cleveland-based restaurant says its melt features 14 kinds of cheese. That includes unexpected appearances from bleu cheese, feta cheese, and goat cheese. Though, the restaurant now says it features 13 kinds of melted cheese (a number that doesn't sound so unlucky in this context), as well as three slices of bread and a hefty pile of fries and cole slaw.

Unlike most challenges featured on the show, there's no time limit on this one, but the Ohio restaurant chain still says 91% of people fail to rise to that untimed challenge. Richman, however, rose to the moment and finished the sandwich.

The Pigzilla falls into a similar category as The Commish; it looks incredible, but it's about five sizes too big. The Pigzilla challenge was created by Papa Buck's BBQ near Savannah, Georgia, and stars a 4-pound monster, loaded with more pulled pork than most people can (or should) eat in a single sitting. It's constructed with 3 pounds of pulled pork and a massive 1-pound bun that is so large it could be hollowed out to make a doghouse. The sandwich also gets doused with the restaurant's barbecue sauce. 

The sandwich isn't just sizeable, it's also made with love. Papa Buck's smokes the meat in-house, giving the Pigzilla Challenge some appeal despite the inevitable fullness that will follow. Of course, you could also get some of that fall-off-the-bone tender pulled pork on a sandwich that doesn't weigh 4 pounds. Nonetheless, the Pigzilla is still out there if you're feeling bold. According to the restaurant website, as of May 2023, 191 people have given it a run, but only 18 have conquered Mt. Pigzilla. 

Roswell, New Mexico, is best known for the conspiracy theories that call it home. It's something that the sandwich shop B'wiches has embraced wholeheartedly. Webb found that embrace in B'wiches' Thanksgiving-themed sandwich dubbed the 1947. It's named after the year of the Roswell Incident, which depending on your stance, is when a weather balloon caused confusion, the government covered up something significant, and/or little green space travelers made a pit stop in the American Southwest.

However, the only thing out of this world about the 1947 is the number of chiles that go into its creation. The show-stopping sandwich features turkey, cream cheese, green hatch chile jam, green chile cornbread dressing, gravy, and garlic parm mayo on toasted sourdough bread.  If that doesn't already sound good enough, B'wiches isn't done with the cornbread dressing when it comes out of the oven. The restaurant gives it texture by frying the stuffing before it hits the sandwich, as owner Kerry Moore showed Webb in the episode. The sandwich is proof that Moore meant it when she told Webb, "We take anything that's traditional and then we New Mexico-fy it."

Head north (even further north than Toronto). In Duluth, Minnesota, you're almost as far north as you can get in the Lower 48. It might be worth the trip, according to Webb, because that's where you'll find Northern Waters Smokehaus cooking up the Cajun Finn sandwich. 

Northern Waters smokes its own meat, including fish, and actually got its start selling smoked meats wholesale. Fortunately for mouths across the north shore, a tentative foray into retail bloomed into a full-blown sandwich haven. The Cajun Finn sandwich is made with smoked Cajun salmon, onion cream cheese, roasted red peppers, pepperoncini, and lettuce on a rustic stirato roll. It might even remind you of a delicious and playful twist on a Lox bagel. The deli reports that the Cajun Finn is still its best-selling sandwich. That is a hearty endorsement given that 29 sandwiches currently grace its menu.

The Haystack sandwich has achieved some level of fame, particularly in northern New York. So, it's not surprising that while visiting Niagara Falls, Richman swung through Lewiston, New York, to get a taste of the cheesesteak twist. At The Silo, a small restaurant with beautiful views, the Haystack is a legend. 

The hoagie is filled with a full pound of rib-eye steak covered in melted mozzarella and topped with crispy hashbrowns straight from the flattop. The delicious mess is set inside a locally-made roll. On a show like "Man v. Food," the Haystack could get lost. It's not the spiciest, most exotic, tallest, or most unexpected sandwich the hosts have dug up, but it has a reputation for good reason. Richman gets to cook one up with Roberta Cicero, the chef who came up with the sandwich. The Silo continues to serve up a boatload of Haystacks to this day in the original or foot-long version.