Whatever Happened To These Popular Bar Rescue Bars?

"Bar Rescue" Season 9 is underway on Paramount Network, as Jon Taffer and his crew set out to save more establishments in the U.S. from going under. In eight seasons and counting, the show has aired more than 250 episodes featuring over 230 bars, ranging from brewhouses in major cities to small-town eateries. The venues may be different, but the premise is always the same: a failing bar receives a lifeline to turn its fortunes around.

According to RealityTVUpdates.com, only 47% of the businesses featured on the show are still open today. It's hard to keep a restaurant in business — even celebrity chefs face challenges to succeeding. Considering that an estimated 30% of restaurants fail in their first year, it's an impressive success rate, especially since impending failure is a requirement to be on the show. Still, time plays a factor. Of the 100+ "Bar Rescue" establishments still open, more than 50% were rescued in the past three seasons of the show, stretching back to 2018. 

"Bar Rescue" has had plenty of successes, but it's not always the stories with happy endings that make for the best television. Of the five top-rated episodes, according to IMDb, two of the bars are still open, two are closed, and one was never remodeled by the show. As it into Season 9, we took a look back at the top-ranked episode from each season, along with a few old favorites, to see where the establishments are today.

With a name like Extremes, it's not surprising to find out that the problems plaguing this California bar were, well, extreme. Originally featured in the Season 2 episode "Bikini Bust," Extremes was renamed Second Base Bar and Grill and managed to turn things around for a while. However, as the profits began rolling in, the owners refused to put any of the money back into the bar. The result was a "Bar Rescue" first, as Second Base received another visit from Taffer in Season 4.

The bar's return episode title, "Second Base, Third Strike," says all there is to say about the double-rescue attempt. When the owners refused to chip in for 30% of the renovation fees, Taffer walked out, leaving Second Base to fend for itself. So far, the bar has done just that, managing to remain open, though customer reviews are bad. Most negative comments center on the interior's strong odor, with the phrase "bio hazard" popping up multiple times on Yelp. Like Angel's, Second Base found itself in the center of tragedy after a fatal shooting took place outside in 2013. Still, the former Extremes remains in business. The bar has an active website, but the focus is more on the scantily clad waitstaff than on the food or drinks.

The O'Face Bar, featured in the Season 3 episode "Punch-Drunk and Trailer-Trashed," comes in at number five on IMDb's list. The rating was likely earned because it was a "Bar Rescue" first, with Taffer walking out on the bar before completing the rescue.

The list of issues facing the Council Bluffs, Iowa, establishment was long when "Bar Rescue" arrived. From disappointing drinks, slow service, and an owner who physically assaulted an employee, things only went from bad to worse after O'Face Bar's appearance on the show. Shortly after the episode aired in early March 2014, the Council Bluffs city council voted to rescind the establishment's liquor license, citing the bar's damaging representation of the city. While the bar did manage to restore its license, the troubles continued when one of the owners was sentenced to jail time after sexually assaulting an employee.

Remarkably, the bar is still open, though it lacks any online presence, and the reviews are rough. The O'Face Bar was deemed unworthy of a rescue thanks in large part to the former owner's history of violence, one that continued well after the cameras stopped rolling. So while it remains in operation, it's hardly a venue Taffer is going to brag about.

Some spots are just beyond saving, which could be said for The Hooch Bar & Grill, star of the Season 4 episode "Vulgar Vixens." The title points to the main problem the bar faced, which came in the form of a rude and verbally abusive owner. While Taffer did his best to rein in the owner's temper, plenty of other issues also arose during the stress test, including a customer discovering mold in their drink.

Ultimately, "Bar Rescue" poured $100,000 worth of renovations into The Hooch and provided it with the name Proving Ground Bar & Grill, but it wasn't enough to save this Michigan establishment. The bar shut down a year after "Vulgar Vixens" aired, though its Yelp page is still active and contains reviews dating back to 2015, many of which include complaints about the owner and waitstaff. Following the bar's closure, the building was demolished and a gas station has since taken up residence in the space.

Number three on IMDb's ranking is Paddy's Pub, star of the Season 5 episode "Things That Go Pahrump in the Night." The episode follows the mother-son duo who own the bar in Pahrump, Nevada. While the mother owned the space, she left it to her adult son to run, and considering he ended up on "Bar Rescue," things clearly did not go well.

In the pantheon of "Bar Rescue" bars, Paddy's Pub was far from the worst. The biggest problems were undertrained (and sometimes hungover) bartenders and a manager who seemed more interested in partying than actually working. There was also the confusing theme. The space was decked out in green, including shamrock decorations in the window, but lacked anything else to distinguish it as an Irish pub. Taffer and his team turned things around without any major breakdowns, and by the end, Paddy's had become Pat's Courtyard Bar. 

When the show stopped by for a check-in six weeks later, things appeared to be going well, but shortly after, the bar reverted to the name Paddy's Pub and dropped many of the changes "Bar Rescue" helped implement. Another name change came shortly after, but becoming the Oasis Bar still wasn't enough to keep Paddy's from falling off the wagon and it closed up shop for good in 2017, less than a year after its episode aired.

It's hard not to end up on "Bar Rescue" with a name like Drunken Donkey. Toss in lime green walls, poorly prepared frozen food, and a beer inventory that far exceeded the establishment's output, and the Texas bar was desperately in need of the famous Jon Taffer touch.

"Bar Rescue" ended up helping to slim down the restaurant's menu, which was bursting with 16 pages of items, and eliminated several positions in the overstaffed bar. By the end of the episode, titled "Green Walls and Donkey Balls," Drunken Donkey was renamed the Butcher and Brew Pub and it was operating with a newfound efficiency.

Nearly five years after the episode aired, the previous name is back, and there is now a second Drunken Donkey location. The restaurant's website describes it as a relaxing place to try craft beer and tasty food with friends while catching the game on TV. And yes, the walls are still green.

The top-ranked episode on IMDb's "Bar Rescue" list is from Season 8. "Magically Atrocious" aired in May 2022, and less than two years later, Cerealholic Cafe & Bar — which was renamed The Loft Elevated Bar + Food — is no more. Part of the bar and restaurant's short shelf life may be attributed to its original, unique concept. The Cerealholic Cafe & Bar was themed around breakfast cereal, with menu items including Bedrock Chicken Strips (house-made chicken strips coated in a Fruity Pebble-infused batter) and a Grilled Loop Sandwich, described as a Fruit Loop-infused triple-decker grilled cheese. At the very least, it's hard to knock the creativity.

However, the cereal-centric concept wasn't profitable, so "Bar Rescue" shifted the menu toward more classic fare in its transition to The Loft. Ultimately, the work may have been all for naught, as The Loft closed just a few months after "Magically Atrocious" aired. The family-owned bar cited family issues as the reason behind the closure. Those looking for a drink in the Ybor City neighborhood of Tampa, Florida, are still in luck, though, as the former Cerealholic space is now occupied by the SpookEasy Lounge, which offers a haunted theme and tea made from the kava root.