Mistakes You're Making When Preparing Chicken

Chicken is great — on that we can all agree, right? Unless you've ascribed to a certain way of living (shout out to the vegetarians and the vegans), chicken can be a fantastic go-to meat for pretty much any occasion. Need a cheap Christmas alternative? Chicken. Got some pesto you need to get rid of? Chicken. Feeling the uncontrollable urge to deep fry something? Friend, you'd better believe that chicken's on the menu.

Unfortunately, chicken's status as a great all-rounder also means that it's often not taken quite as seriously by home cooks as, say, beef, pork or duck. All too many people tend to think of it as an "easy" choice of meat, but the truth is that getting it right — getting it really right, we mean — is actually pretty tough. You may even be surprised at just how many of these poultry-based mistakes you're still making in the kitchen. Sort it out, yeah? That chicken deserves better.

Pre-frozen food is never your friend in the kitchen, and that goes just as much for chicken as it does anything else. See, the one thing you want in chicken is juiciness, and that juiciness comes from the meat containing a suitable amount of water. During the freezing process, however, meat dries out and loses much of its water content — meaning the eventual, cooked chicken is going to be almost totally devoid of those juices.

According to James Wilschke, executive chef at Hollywood's Filifera restaurant, you can't always trust a "fresh, never frozen" label, either. "I'm sure there are grocery stores that are overstocked on product," he told Food & Wine. "And if they don't want it to spoil, they might freeze it to just extend the life of it." If it's good meat you're after, your best bet will be heading to a butcher and sourcing your meat from there.

By and large, the points we've hit so far on chicken prep have dealt with ensuring the meat you're using is high-quality and suitable, and results in deliciousness rather than disappointment. This, however, is an altogether more serious element of the cooking process. Put short: never wash raw chicken.

According to the NHS, running raw chicken under the tap will likely increase your risk of food poisoning from campylobacter bacteria. This is because the water droplets which splash onto the chicken from the tap can travel over a foot and half in any direction — onto cooking equipment, clothing, surfaces and, more likely than not, your own hands. And it really doesn't take much for you to be infected with campylobacter, a form of poisoning which causes stomach pain, severe diarrhea, and vomiting for up to five days. Worse (though rarer) complications can lead to arthritis, irritable bowel syndrome, and damage to your nervous system. Just trust the cooking process to kill bacteria — there's no need to rinse it.

One thing worth remembering — especially if you're cooking chicken thighs — is that there's never any good reason to remove the skin. In fact, some grocery stores even sell their own pretty-looking boneless skinless chicken thighs, hoping to appeal to people who think the skins are just a little too gross. Take it from us, though: these aren't worth your time.

Chicken skin has a number of uses during cooking. It acts as a kind of sponge full of tasty juices, and if you leave it on, they'll be released to the meat during the cooking process. It also protects that same meat from the heat, and allows the thigh to cook at a slower pace and retain its moisture. If you take the skin off before cooking, there's a good chance that what you find on the other end is a dry, tasteless chicken thigh that might as well be an overdone breast. If you really, really don't like the skin (but why?) then remove it after cooking instead.

The word "dry" might seem like anathema to anyone wanting to cook up a good chicken, but the truth is that drying out your meat after brining is a must-do for any poultry cook worth their salt. According to James Wilshcke, doing this will help encourage the caramelized outer crust which makes all good chicken even better "People want to get really crispy meat, and the general rule of cooking is moisture is the enemy of caramelization," he told Food & Wine. "When you want to get meat crispy, you want the skin as dry as possible."

You should air dry the meat out of its packaging in the fridge for up to four hours (though much longer can occasionally be more suitable, and Wilschke himself lets it dry for a day or two if he's making fried chicken), before taking it out and patting it down with a clean paper towel.

Marinating chicken, like brining, can be an excellent source of flavor for your meat. But it is possible to get it wrong — and doing so can leave your chicken in any number of bad states. If it's exposed to the marinade for too long, it can go from being tender to mushy and stringy. If it doesn't spend enough time marinating, it'll fail to soak up all those spices, making the whole ordeal a massive waste of time.

The golden rule is this: never marinate chicken for more than 24 hours. And you don't need to come close to that deadline, either — marinating chicken for only 15 to 20 minutes can still completely transform it. In the end, leaving your meat in marinade for two days does nothing except ruin the chicken and waste your precious time. If you've really got that time to spare, stick to brining. It'll come out far better.

This might go against the instincts of anyone who's particularly safety-conscious when it comes to handling and preparing raw meat, but it's actually a good idea to let your chicken sit out for a little while before you cook it. Tempering chicken essentially allows it to come to room temperature, which has a few key benefits: it'll help your chicken hit that key temperature (more on that in a minute) more quickly, helps the chicken cook more evenly all the way through since the center isn't colder than the edges, and the end result will be juicer, too. And that's never a bad thing, is it?

As long as you're careful, this process isn't going to cause you any harm, either. Don't allow it to sit out anywhere it can come into contact with other food, wash your hands, and don't let it sit out for too long (no longer than two hours) and you'll be just fine.

This is another common mistake made during the actual process of cooking. If you're pan-frying, pan-searing or sauteing chicken, you ought to make sure the pan is never overcrowded. This is because one of the main things which gives chicken its flavor is browning, a reaction which happens when the food comes into contact with very high temperatures. Unfortunately, if the pan is too crowded the moisture that comes off the chicken will have no room to spread and evaporate and end up turning into steam or water instead. Instead of browning, the chicken will end up steaming. In the end, you'll end up with poached chicken.

This is all easily avoidable — just make sure there's plenty of room for the chicken in the pan, and the pieces aren't overlapping or smashed up against each other — but getting it wrong can completely ruin your dish. And when you've spent so much time tenderizing, brining and seasoning the meat, that's going to feel just a little heartbreaking.

Wait, just a minute! Hear this one out before you nope on out of here!

When you're cooking chicken, you want it tender, right? One way to do that is to soak it — not in a more typical kind of marinade, but in milk. It really does work, and we found out why: lactic acid.

While other marinade ingredients you might think of first — like lemon juice and vinegar — work their magic to tenderize the meat because of acid, milk works in a similar way due to the lactic acid present in it. Lactic acid breaks down meat proteins and makes it that much more tender, and that's a win. Some suggest there's a double whammy going on here, and the calcium in milk also has tenderizing benefits... although that's less scientifically proven. 

And if you're making fried chicken, you should definitely use a milk soak — specifically, buttermilk. According to Robby Melvin from Time Inc. Food Studios (via My Recipes), those acids in the buttermilk help break down the chicken's skin, which help add the exact amount of crispiness you want, at the same time it helps keep the breading sticking to the chicken. The New York Times suggests that it's exactly this principle that's at work whether you're frying or roasting your chicken, and they also say buttermilk helps give your aromatics an extra kick. It's a win no matter how you look at it!