The Best And Worst Fast Food Super Bowl Commercials Of All Time

No event is more American than the Super Bowl. The extravagant spectacle surrounding the annual NFL championship game represents the apex of U.S. culture, offering an unrivaled viewing experience — whether or not you're concerned with the actual game of football being played. Therein lies the unique beauty of the Super Bowl, though. Because even a person wholly uninterested in the sport itself can find something to enjoy amidst the bevy of live performances, mountains of Super Bowl party foods, and occasionally-cinematic and often star-studded commercials.

Now, considering more than 90 million U.S. viewers have watched the Super Bowl every year since 2006 (via Statista), it's no wonder companies covet commercial time during the game. But that colossal number of built-in, guaranteed viewers means the privilege of airing an advertisement during the Super Bowl isn't cheap, with a 30-second commercial costing as much as $7 million dollars in 2023 (via Ad Age). Still, since a well-done Super Bowl commercial can generate substantial nationwide buzz, the allure is obvious to any company — and fast food restaurants are no exception. In fact, countless commercials, from numerous fast food chains, have aired during the Super Bowl's 57 years (and counting) — far too many to ever consider ranking. So, instead, we focused on the high (and low) points from the fast food industry's big game offerings, and present the best and worst fast food Super Bowl commercials of all time.

It was fairly easy slotting this 2003 Subway commercial (which aired during Super Bowl XXXVII, according to Ad Age) as one of the worst advertisements from the big game's history. Because anything to do with the sandwich chain's now-disgraced former spokesman, Jared Fogle, has to be held in consideration for the worst of anything — at least in light of his 2015 conviction for possessing and distributing child pornography, according to The New York Times, among other horrifying transgressions.

To be clear, there's nothing particularly offensive about the ad itself, although it is sort of idiotic. After all, it's not entirely clear why Jared's supposed dream revolved around him discovering a Subway restaurant in his living room. Wasn't his entire celebrity based on the notion of walking to and from Subway to help increase his daily activities? Either way, we'd love to forget this creepy sex offender ever existed, but since we can't erase the countless appearances he made on our television screens during the 2000s, we'll have to be content with bestowing a dishonorable mention for this Subway Super Bowl commercial.

For some Super Bowl commercials, the line between good and bad is clear. Sure, extenuating circumstances might push a commercial into terrible territory on occasion. But oftentimes? The worst commercials are just bad in general. So while we look up to Charles Barkley — even if he is "not a role model" — we can't help but describe his appearance in a 2010 Taco Bell commercial (which aired during Super Bowl XLIV) as embarrassingly forgettable.

Why, exactly, anyone thought the mashup of Barkley and Dr. Seuss-style rhyming would be a winner is unclear. But we aren't alone in finding this commercial to be an offensive assault on our eyes, ears, and creative sensibilities. In fact, the ad ranked among the least-successful from that year's game by both The Christian Science Monitor and Time. Of course, while we don't necessarily need a pair of publications to tell us this Taco Bell Super Bowl commercial was a loser, it does bolster our stance. Perhaps the commercial could have been salvaged with a different celebrity behind the rhyme (the rhyme) — but we doubt it.

At first glance, you may not entirely understand our logic behind penalizing this 1998 Pizza Hut commercial (which aired during Super Bowl XXXII, according to Ad Age) for including a digitally-resurrected Elvis Presley. After all, we just praised Burger King for its decision to utilize footage of Andy Warhol in their 2019 commercial. But there's a marked difference between using a clip of a man actually eating a Whopper to advertise, well, Whoppers, versus the "Forrest Gump"-inspired superimposition of a long-deceased celebrity to sell pizza.

At least Pizza Hut didn't throw caution to the wind and utilize the late King's image without permission, since his estate evidently approved the pizza chain's inclusion (via Sports Business Journal). But the simple fact the man's family signed off on the choice to show Presley dancing at a modern-day Pizza Hut doesn't mean it was the right decision. The bigger issue, though, might be the fact that the commercial just isn't very entertaining. We suppose a brief appearance by a then-unknown, pre-"Freaks and Geeks" James Franco is notable. But it's not nearly enough to overcome the incredibly lame commercial, or its use of a then-novel technology.

How many people even remember the character Herb the Nerd, Burger King's attempted answer to Wendy's famous "where's-the-beef?" spokeswoman Clara Peller (via Nation's Restaurant News)? Exactly. Frankly, to say this $40 million dollar dud of an ad campaign was a failure is an understatement, as the debut of Herb the Nerd in a 1986 commercial (which aired during Super Bowl XX, according to Ad Age) landed with a thud.

If there's a reason Herb was unable to etch his name in the annals of Super Bowl commercial history, it may be the spectacularly simple fact that he was, well, sort of boring. As author Al Ries told Nation's Restaurant News in 1986, the commercial (and character) wasn't "as humorous as it possibly could be," noting the portrayal of Herb was "too subtle" and "not exaggerated enough" to connect with consumers. Despite Burger King pouring millions of dollars into it, Herb the Nerd didn't make much of an impact as a Super Bowl commercial. Even an appearance at Wrestlemania 2 (via Tampa Tribune) several months after his doomed first appearance wasn't enough to leave a lasting impression on the world. As a result, nearly four decades later, this Burger King Super Bowl commercial belongs among the worst to ever air.

We'll be honest and admit there's nothing all that terrible about this 2022 commercial at first glance (which aired during Super Bowl LVI, according to Billboard). In fact, we'll even admit the idea of being stumped about one's fast food order when put on the spot brings a slight smile, since it does contain a kernel of truth. But any goodwill accumulated by the advertisement's execution is immediately washed away after a surprise appearance by the one and only Kanye West.

Look, we're not going to debate the talent or artistry of the controversial man known in 2023 as Ye. But his very public, very long-running inexcusable behavior in recent years — which included him proudly declaring his wholehearted admiration for Adolf Hitler in late 2022 (via Rolling Stone) — makes it impossible to find Yeezy anything but abhorrent. Consequently, we weren't thrilled to see his surprise cameo in this 2022 Super Bowl ad. And after a year of further decline, we're inclined to place this Kanye West-featuring McDonald's Super Bowl commercial among the worst of all time.

Frankly, if you're a New England Patriots fan (like this writer), there's a case to be made that this 2015 Papa John's commercial (which aired at the end of Super Bowl XLIX) belongs among the best. After all, for Patriots fans, there's no reason to be anything but delighted by such an error. But, objectively speaking, a commercial congratulating the Seattle Seahawks for winning back-to-back championships — mere moments after the team had actually lost to the Patriots (via Washington Post) — was undoubtedly embarrassing. And it deserves a spot among the very worst Super Bowl commercials as a result.

Now, it's not necessarily Papa John's fault that the Super Bowl equivalent of "Dewey Defeats Truman" aired when it shouldn't have. As the official sponsor of that year's game, it's completely understandable that the fast food pizza chain might have produced two different commercials — one congratulating each team — to ensure a quick airing regardless of the winner (via SB Nation). But coming on the heels of a heartbreaking, last-second loss by the Seahawks, the commercial was akin to rubbing salt into a wound at its rawest. So no matter who's to blame for the blunder, this commercial will go down as one of the worst in Super Bowl history.

The decision to cut Pepe Le Pew from "Space Jam: A New Legacy" in 2021 (via Deadline) felt like a long time coming. After all, it's not as though we needed the #MeToo movement to recognize a lecherous cartoon skunk was best left as a relic from a bygone era. Clearly, though, Pepe Le Pew has no place in modern society — which only crystallized our belief the cartoon character's starring appearance in a 1986 commercial for McDonald's (which aired during Super Bowl XX, according to Ad Age) was one of the worst we've ever seen.

Actually, it's not just a matter of Pepe Le Pew's appearance that dampens the viewing experience of this 1986 McDonald's ad. More than that, the fact the character was chosen to shill for the fast food conglomerate's famously-failed product, the McDLT, does it no favors, either. Maybe McDonald's should have simply aired the original McDLT commercial (starring an exhaustingly-energetic and young Jason Alexander) instead. It might not have been much better quality-wise, but at least it wouldn't be marred by the queasy actions of a sexual predator skunk.