8 Store-Bought Hot Dogs That Don't Use Pure Beef & 8 That Do

Hot dogs are an essential part of summer grilling in the U.S., but how often do you think about what's actually in your hot dogs? While some people would rather not, others have very specific tastes and look for hot dogs with specific meats, blends, seasonings, casings, or organic ingredients. Some brands distinguish between hot dog products with the more traditional names, like frankfurter (or franks), wiener, and sausage. The definitions associated with each of those names have changed and gotten less helpful over time as the process of making hot dogs has developed.

All-beef hot dogs are just one of the many types of hot dogs available, along with chicken, turkey, and pork. If you're a fan of beef hot dogs, you might assume that the pack of dogs you're picking up that's labeled "original" or "classic" might mean that it's 100% beef, but more often than not, you'd be wrong. We looked at 16 different hot dog brands, paying special attention to eight hot dogs that we assumed were made with beef (but actually aren't), and brands that are making partial-beef or non-beef hot dogs (and doing it well). We also looked at eight brands that either specialize in 100% beef hot dogs, or have what we think are special all-beef hot dog offerings. Here's what we found.

Ball Park Brand hot dogs are synonymous with summertime and baseball, either at a little league game down the street or tailgating in front of the stadium. But we were surprised to learn that Ball Park's Classic Franks don't contain beef — at least not in the way we were expecting. The hot dogs are made with chicken and pork, both declared on the front of the package and the first ingredients listed on the nutrition label. Interestingly, the dogs do contain beef stock, which is listed in the ingredients.

The USDA has specific rules that dictate how hot dogs can be named, including clear statements about the meat used to produce hot dogs, what species it originated from, and how it was produced (either mechanically separated or hand-trimmed). With that said, beef stock isn't meat, although it's produced with meat. So, technically, some of the flavor of these particular Ball Park Franks comes from beef. This practice is a little deceptive, and might come as a surprise to anyone who thinks they're eating a beef hot dog — and those who might be intentionally trying to avoid beef products.

Known for its entirely plant-based "meat" products, Field Roast got its start in Seattle in 1997. The company offers specialty plant-based sausages, burgers, hot dogs, pepperoni, larger-format roasts, and appetizers like nuggets, corn dogs, and buffalo wings. The Signature Stadium Dog is Field Roast's primary hot dog offering, is entirely vegan, and contains no GMOs. 

The primary protein listed in the ingredients is pea protein, which we've also seen pop up in other meat and dairy alternative products. It also contains protein from brown rice and fava beans. The dogs are colored with beet, and seasoned with garlic, paprika, and black pepper. True to its name, this dog is made to impart roasty flavors, which it achieves by using hardwood smoked sugar in the mix before getting "smoked to perfection." While the Signature Stadium Dog doesn't specifically contain nuts, the dog's nutrition information points out that, due to the pea protein, those with peanut allergies could have issues with the product.

MorningStar Farms isn't trying to be something it's not. The brand eschews references to baseball and drops the vague labeling act, getting straight to the point. Currently, MorningStar Farms offers Veggie Dogs and Veggie Corn Dogs, both suitable for vegetarian and vegan consumption. Instead of the deli case, you'll find these veggie dogs on the freezer aisle.

Nutritionally speaking, there's a lot going on for these veggie dogs, even if you don't follow a vegetarian or vegan diet. We compared the nutrition labels of the MorningStar Farms Veggie Dogs with the Oscar Mayer Original Uncured Wieners, and the differences are clear. The serving sizes are very similar, with the veggie dog coming in at 40 grams and the Oscar Mayer weighing 45 grams. The calorie count for the former is 60 calories, compared with 110 calories for the latter. The veggie dogs have a mere 0.5 grams of fat per dog, while Oscar Mayer has 10 grams each. What we think is especially interesting is that the veggie dogs have 9 grams of protein per dog, while the Oscar Mayer Originals only have 5 grams each.

Organic Valley has an understandably small offering of hot dogs, and is one of the few more widely available organic brands we came across in our search. The brand offers only two types of hot dogs, an Uncured Pasture-Raised Turkey Hot Dog, which we were expecting, and an Uncured 100% Grass-Fed Beef Hot Dog, which we weren't. The ingredients list for each hot dog is refreshingly straightforward, each including water, sea salt, organic spices, organic onion powder, organic garlic powder, and cultured celery juice powder. While, yes, Organic Valley offers an appealing beef hot dog option, we'd also be tempted to reach for the turkey hot dog too, given that it's given the same treatment as the beef dog.

The downside to these organic hot dogs wasn't especially surprising — the price per pack is noticeably higher than many of the other options. While prices will vary widely by location, stock, and demand, we found 6-piece packs of Organic Valley hot dogs in the $10 ballpark (pun intended). In comparison, we found 10-piece packs of Oscar Mayer Original wieners for as low as $2.50 from Walmart.

Hebrew National franks are all made from 100% beef, don't contain any by-products, and are made from kosher beef. In fact, there are many similarities between the Hebrew National brand and Nathan's Famous hot dogs. Hebrew National was founded about a decade before Nathan's, also in NYC in 1905. But it wasn't a one-man hot dog stand. Hebrew National began as a kosher sausage factory on the Lower East Side in Manhattan, founded by Theodore Krainin, who was also an immigrant (although he was from Russia, not Poland). But the Hebrew National Sausage Company was sold out of bankruptcy in 1928 to Isadore Pinckowitz, whose family owned the company until 1993.

Hebrew National offers eight different all-beef frank styles, including the standard, bun-length, jumbo, reduced fat, 97% fat-free, uncured, quarter-pound franks, and knockwurst. So, if you're looking for a reduced-fat all-beef hot dog, Hebrew National can provide you with options.

Like Trader Joe's, we expected to find more variety and alternative meat hot dog choices in the Whole Foods Market store brand selection. But 365 by Whole Foods currently only offers organic uncured grass-fed beef hot dogs. The dogs themselves appear to be similar in almost every way to the Trader Joe's store brand, down to the ingredients and the order they're listed in on the label, with one exception. The 365 by Whole Foods Market hot dogs include organic paprika at the end of the ingredients list, whereas the Trader Joe's dogs do not. The six-pack of hot dogs from Whole Foods is also a little more expensive than the competition, priced at $7.49 in our store location. The Whole Foods brand is labeled as dairy-free, paleo-friendly, sugar-conscious, and keto-friendly.

Where Whole Foods has the advantage is not with its own store brand but with the wider selection of other brands it carries, which Trader Joe's does not. Depending on your location, you may find vegan brands available, like Upton's Naturals and LightLife, and other organic meat-based brands, like Applegate and Fork in the Road.

At this point, you might be starting to wonder if all of the major all-beef hot dog brands originated in New York City in the early 1900s — and while there are certainly plenty that didn't, many of them clearly did. Joining the list is Sabrett, a company that might be lesser-known outside of the New York area, but is instantly recognizable by the iconic blue and yellow umbrellas that shade hot dog pushcarts all over NYC. It's the essential "dirty water dog," which is really a term of endearment (even if it doesn't sound like one). Sabrett's frankfurters are also packaged and sold in grocery stores, along with hamburgers, condiments, and appetizers. 

In business since 1926, this lesser-known brand sells predominantly beef frankfurters. Sabrett hot dogs are available in most of the usual formats that we've seen other companies carry, including natural (sheep) casing, skinless, hot and spicy, and all-natural skinless uncured. Sabrett also makes four styles of cocktail franks wrapped in puff pastry.

We were delighted to see that Applegate has a slightly wider selection of flavors to choose from, compared to other organic brands, including seven hot dogs and one corn dog. Four of the hot dogs (and the corn dog) in the lineup are all beef. All of the options are uncured and made with 100% grass-fed pasture-raised beef. Both organic options are the same dog, just in two different sizes. The "natural" dogs have mostly the same ingredient spread as the organic dogs, without the use of organic ingredients — although none of the ingredients are artificial.

But the most exciting hot dog in the Applegate collection is The Do Good Dog Uncured Beef Hot Dog (okay, that's a mouthful). It's also made with 100% grass-fed beef and the same ingredients and seasoning as the other dogs. According to Applegate, what sets this beef apart is that it comes from cattle "raised on verified regenerative U.S. grasslands," and involves herd grazing practices that help keep the overall impact on the environment and climate change to a minimum.