Canned Beef Stew, Ranked From Worst To Best, According To Customers

Mmm, beef stew. It's not exactly something you'd expect to come canned, but it sure does make for a convenient meal when you're craving deeply comforting beefy flavors but don't want to invest the time, effort, and energy getting a proper stew cooked at home. We feel you. It's for that reason that we have set out to inspect the canned beef stews already available to find out which are the best (and worst) varieties out there.

We'll issue a fair warning here and say that some of our picks are truly stews, and some are technically "soups" though they may function the same with stew-based ingredients. Our product picks for ranking, as well as the levels by which we ranked each canned beef stew, were determined by our personal experience, careful examination of customer reviews, and attention to specific details, like pricing and ingredients, when necessary. Ready to slurp up the savory details of today's post? Join us as we dish out our list of canned beef stew, ranked from worst to best.

We're a bit shocked by customer reactions to this one, but, as always, we're here to dish the deets. Despite the delicious images of hearty beef and potatoes with savory mushrooms (yes, we're mushroom fans over here), we were instead met with reviews that featured vomiting emojis in the midst of harsh statements. So, what were these critics so upset about? Many customers believe that this particular Campbell's flavor tastes almost identical to dog food. And there weren't only one or two comments like this either — there were many patrons who joined in chorus to proclaim the same thing.

In addition to the disgusting dog food taste and smell comes the fact that customers attest there is little to no meat and potatoes in this grab. Instead, customers complain that it's primarily liquid leaving much to be desired, especially when compared to the enticing picture on the can. Oh, well. We suppose this just shows you can't judge a book by its cover; despite its savory imagery, this is one stew-like soup you'll want to leave on the shelf.

On a super tight budget but simultaneously craving a large bowl of beef stew? If so, you're in luck. Southgate Beef Stew can be purchased at Dollar Tree and online, but be warned, this product isn't loved by most. Now, granted, we understand that a beef stew that comes from the dollar store shouldn't be held to very high standards. At the same time, we at least think you should be informed about what to expect — even if your expectations aren't very high. With that said, many customers insist that the meat is rubbery and the flavor quite plain. Several people have recommended you "doctor" this one up a bit, either with spices like salt, pepper, and onion powder, or by simply serving it alongside other items like buttered bread to make things more interesting.

Despite these somewhat negative reviews, we're also pleased to inform you that there are some people out there who believe this stew is incredibly tasty. Dollar Tree patrons in particular seem impressed with it, with several hailing it as very tasty or even their favorite canned beef stew. At this point, we'd say how you'll interpret this one will likely depend on your expectations and what you think constitutes a good beef stew; but at only a little over a dollar per can, you might as well try it and draw your own conclusions.

Campbell's Chunky Beef Soup With Country Vegetables may not technically be beef stew, but many customers agree that with the vegetables, thicker broth, and overall heartiness of the soup, it functions similarly. With that said, though we notice that this Campbell's rendition of beef stew definitely has its fans, it also has left quite a few disappointed. Some think the soup tastes wonderful, just like a good old-fashioned traditional bowl of stew, while others think it is virtually tasteless and wouldn't consider purchasing it again. It likely depends on your taste buds and expectations, but this is one of those soups that definitely garners split reviews depending on who you ask.

Also, because this soup is so polarizing, we thought taking a glance at the ingredients might help us come to a better decision about whether or not this soup was worthy of a higher or lower rank. Sadly, we find many of the ingredients included in the soup disappointing, with caramel coloring, modified cornstarch, and other additives lurking in the can. With all things considered, we think this Campbell's soup deserves a middle-of-the-road ranking — it isn't terrible, but it isn't the best either.

We were surprised at the customer opinion on this one, especially given that this is one of the lowest-priced beef vegetable stew soups we've seen on the market. And while we know we shouldn't always equate inexpensive with lower quality, it is often the case that you get what you pay for. In this case, Great Value has outdone itself by offering what customers consider great-tasting flavor with plenty of meat chunks and veggies to indulge in.

Now, we will say that we have found a few comments that seem to conflict with the opinion of the majority, with a few calling the stew-like soup tasteless with not enough meat. Confused yet? We get it — as you'll soon learn, many soups and stews have a share of fans and haters, often with conflicting opinions. If it helps any, one customer explains that though this Great Value beef soup isn't exactly awesome, it's at least close to Campbell's soup quality but for a lower price. No matter the reason behind these discrepancies in opinion, we're going to rank this one a little higher on the list than we may have otherwise. The majority seems to adore this soup, and for that, we're willing to give props where props are due.

Progresso Beef Pot Roast With Country Vegetables is a pick that's better than most. This is one we've tried before, and can personally attest that the meat in the soup is quite heartier than other brands you may come across. Other reviewers agree that this one tastes delicious and is easy to serve with other items for a hearty meal. One customer states that she buys two cans of it, places it in a casserole dish, and tops it with biscuits before baking it up for a comforting evening meal.

Other facets of this canned beef stew we'd like to point out include the price point and the fact that it is gluten-free. You pay about $2 bucks per 18.5-ounce can (at the time of publication), which is actually a little cheaper than some of the poorer canned beef stew brands we've reviewed. In addition, for those of you avoiding gluten, you can safely eat this particular Progresso flavor without needing to worry about getting sick. Just be sure to look for the "gluten-free" stamp on the label before eating. With all things considered, we definitely think this is one of the better canned beef stew grabs out there.

An emergency meal that actually tastes good? Almost sounds too good to be true, doesn't it? We thought so, too — that is until we ran across Mountain House Beef Stew. We haven't yet seen this brand touted in stores yet, but boy, are we glad we found them online. What's impressive about this brand of canned beef stew is that not only do customers think it tastes delicious, but it also has a superstar lineup of ingredients with virtually no additives found anywhere in sight.

In addition, Mountain House Beef Stew can be reconstituted using only water and is backed by a 30-year taste guarantee. As if that isn't enough, customers seem to adore this canned beef stew variety, saying that there are plenty of veggies in it and that it looks and tastes just like beef stew made at home. Still, we're open and honest enough to acknowledge complaints, many of which point to a lack of meat in the stew and the runnier consistency compared to "real" beef stew options. When coupled with its price point and stellar ingredients, this nourishing gluten-free beef stew is deserving of the No.1 spot.