Costco Vs Sam's Club Pumpkin Pie: Which Is The Better Value?

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

When fall rolls around, tasty seasonal desserts start resurfacing on grocery store shelves, including the fan-favorite, giant pumpkin pies at Costco and Sam's Club. When feeding a crowd for Thanksgiving or a game-day celebration, it's always smart to look for the best value items, especially when comparing similar products. Between Costco and Sam's Club pumpkin pies — which are both 12 inches in diameter and 58 ounces — officially, the better value is Sam's Club (based solely on price), but the price difference is as miniscule as it can get.  

Costco's Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie costs $5.99 in the store ($6.80 online through same-day delivery), while Sam's Club's Member's Mark Pumpkin Pie costs $5.98 in-store ($5.98 plus delivery fees online). Is the one-cent price difference a direct taunt from Sam's Club to Costco? One can only guess. 

It's no secret Costco and Sam's Club are in direct competition with each other as members-only, bulk warehouse giants. Naturally, customers often compare similar items between the two, with each club having its own set of loyal shoppers that go to bat for them. However, Costco tends to be more popular than Sam's Club, at least according to Reddit, and generates far more revenue than Sam's.  Still, there may be some things that Sam's Club does better than Costco (like offering curbside pickup). Find out more about Costco's versus Sam's Club's pumpkin pie ingredients, taste, and customer reviews.

Sam's Club's pumpkin pie is prepared fresh in-house daily, and its filling consists of 100% pumpkin puree, brown sugar, cinnamon, and spices. It contains seven grams of protein and 4% of your daily value for fiber, among other nutrients like calcium, iron, and potassium. The customer-favorite seasonal pie has a 4.6 out of 5.0 rating on Sam's website with over 7,500 reviews. One October 2026 five-star review read, "Good flavor and crust. Excellent value for the money."

Meanwhile, Costco's pumpkin pie looks fairly similar to Sam's (albeit darker in color), is also prepared fresh in-house, and has similar ingredients like pumpkin, sugar, spices, and enriched wheat flour. It also contains 4% of daily value for fiber and six grams of protein. The iconic Thanksgiving dessert receives generally positive reviews across the internet. "Nearly four pounds of pie for under ten bucks is the most reliable joy in retail," shared one Redditor.

In our review of Sam's Club Vs Costco pumpkin pie, the taste-tester found Sam's pie to be more custardy with a thick, cheesecake-like texture, while Costco's has greater pumpkin flavor and a lighter consistency. The reviewer preferred Costco's pumpkin pie due to the crust being less tough than Sam's. Still, other people enjoy Sam's pie over Costco's. At that low price, it doesn't hurt to buy both for your family to conduct your own taste test.