Coffee Mate Creamers, Ranked Worst To Best

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

It's no secret that Americans love coffee, whether it's a bold brew from a local coffee shop, a quick pod at home, or a flavorful concocted treat at either location. They love it strong, mild, regular, and sweet, and they can consume one or multiple cups each day. American coffee habits are certainly varied across the land, but if you're not a fan of flavored, sweet coffees, you may be unaware of just how many flavors of creamer are available in grocery stores throughout the country.

Nestlé S.A is one of the largest producers of coffee creamer in the United States, and Coffee Mate is their iconic brand. There are over 25 flavors in its lineup, with options that range in availability from all year round to seasonal and even to limited-edition specialties. For new as well as experienced coffee palettes, there is a flavor for everyone, whether with sugar or without. Try one, or three, or try them all, but with such a large array of options, there is almost definitely a favorite to be found. This guide will help you explore the expansive world of Coffee Mate creamers available on the shelves countrywide.

Chocolate and caramel: It's a decadent combination that's found in an array of candies and baked goods worldwide. Some people would argue that the duo is one of the most perfect flavor sets to ever coexist, and would they be wrong? Love it or leave it, it's fair to say that you should expect a close imitation of such a classic pairing from Coffee Mate, but this chocolate caramel creamer falls flat.

Zero sugar is the only option currently available for this particular flavor. It's possible that the lack of authentic sweetness is the reason you won't find the luscious, chocolatey taste that you would desire from a coffee shop-quality treat. The reviews on this option are mixed, with some confirming that the chocolate taste is lacking, and others who have been having a hard time finding the product in stores in the first place. Perhaps this creamer is better M.I.A., since it's not one of the tastiest you could buy.

This flavor of Coffee Mate's Natural Bliss line contains dairy, unlike most of their other, traditional creamers. It's made with all-natural milk and cream, so don't forget to read the label if you happen to pick this up. It does contain authentic caramel flavoring and real cane sugar, which stays true to their "natural" pledge. However, the caramel doesn't have a strong enough taste to put you in a state of "bliss."

Reviewers on Target.com have reported the insufficient caramel flavor and overall lack of sweetness. Some claim that this is yet another flavor that has changed all of a sudden, but used to be okay. Buyers are generally unhappy with this creamer's higher-than-normal price, sometimes over $5 depending on where you live, for the average 32-ounce bottle. This alone might not be worth it for a creamer that isn't as delectable and creamy as you'd hope it would be.

Have you ever lazily awoken, eager to dive into a bold mug of coffee to get your day started, then opened the refrigerator to find that you're all out of your favorite creamer? (Or even just milk?) It can be a crucial moment that disrupts your morning routine, but having a powdered creamer tucked away in your pantry provides an ideal alternative. For this reason, it's always a good idea to keep one handy, and this sugar-free vanilla caramel flavor is the one to go for.

This sugar-free flavor allows you to control your sugar intake without sacrificing flavor, and it's perfect in case you have guests over who prefer their drinks that way. Altogether, you can't go wrong with this one. But a heads up: Some reviewers say that this particular flavor is hard to find. If you're lucky enough to locate it on a grocery store shelf near you, you'll be thankful to find it in your own pantry at home when you're all out of your regular favorite — or just want to shake things up.

Amaretto is an Italian sweet liqueur that's derived from apricot pits that boast a distinctive almond flavor, starting out with a bittersweet bite that soon gives way to a cloying taste profile. It's an additive that's used in popular cocktails and baked goods such as amaretti cookies and tiramisu. In this non-alcoholic coffee creamer form, it works well with a robust coffee to add a more rounded-out flavor.

As prominent a taste as amaretto is, so too are the overwhelmingly positive reviews. It maintains a 4.8 out of 5 rating on the Coffee Mate page, and the love has spread over to Nestle's Amazon shop as well, where it's available to purchase in miniature .375-ounce individual cups for easy, on-the-go access. Reviewer Mertzie says that even homemade coffee creamer doesn't compare to the quality of this product and that it will be hard for any other flavor to beat it. Another, by a Kroger reviewer named WeDemandAmaretto (very fitting), claims that they drove three hours in search of this creamer, stating that it doesn't seem to be available year-round. But given its immense popularity, perhaps that should change.

As the years go by and seasons come and go, we've seen throughout many crisp autumns that pumpkin spice-flavored everything is here to stay. As Business Insider reports, pumpkin spice was popularized among millennials by the ultra-famous Starbucks latte of the same flavor. The generation who grew up with pumpkin spice lattes has come to cherish it as part of their seasonal traditions each and every year.

With Coffee Mate's creamer, it's easier than ever to create your own pumpkin spice latte at home. The flavors that make up pumpkin spice (nutmeg, cinnamon, and cloves, to name a few) are vivid and full in this creamer. As one reviewer, Fernanda A., puts it, "a little goes a long way," and even the zero sugar substitute is not too shabby. Whether you pour in a little or a lot, whether you prefer it hot, iced, or frozen, this pumpkin spice creamer does not disappoint and is sure to spice up the autumn season.

This has to be Coffee Mate's most invigorating and refreshing creamer to date. It's a true and sweet coconut flavor that instantly sends you to an imaginary tropical paradise any time of year. Yes, it's available in stores all year round, so there's no need to wait for the sweltering summer months to dive into this refreshing pool of creamer. While it is fairly sweet, there is a zero-sugar version that is equally tasty.

Coconut cream is a widely used ingredient that can thicken up both sweet and savory dishes, whether it's a coconut cake or a curry. It can even be used as a dairy substitute in many recipes that require yogurts or heavy creams. In this creamer, Coffee Mate remains consistent with its use of dairy-free ingredients, but it's always best to check the label according to your own dietary needs. This is another flavor that is extremely adaptable — add a splash to a protein shake or a bowl of oatmeal for a special and sweet coconut zing.

While other creamers are widely versatile for use in a variety of sweet coffee treats and desserts, the absolute best Coffee Mate flavor had to be even more than that, and that is why hazelnut takes the crown. Hazelnut is popular in any season due to the nutty aromatics that make it appealing in various sweet treats, from cakes and cookies to hot chocolate and even coffee-based cocktails. Hazelnut is also used in savory dishes, pairing well with butternut squash and mushrooms. And who could forget Nutella, a chocolate hazelnut spread that's become a worldwide favorite? The flavor is simply a classic.

This creamer is available year-round in a wide array of sizes: bottles of 16, 32, and 64 ounces, a 1.5-liter bottle with a pump, single-serve cups, and even a zero-sugar version.

A review by Lisarb states, "I always come back to the hazelnut" after having tried various other flavors in the past. Hazelnut is hard to beat and all too easy to return to; it has an all-encompassing flavor that is both pleasant and familiar, and that's why it deserves top billing as Coffee Mate's best creamer.