The Best Pizza Peels Of 2023
We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.
Pizza is a popular and widely consumed food around the globe. And there's a good reason why. The combination of delicious crust, savory toppings, and rich sauces can be irresistible. Commonly shared with friends and family, pizza is also a great way to bring people together. The crowd-pleaser can also be easily customized to suit different tastes and dietary requirements.
While there are plenty of pizza delivery and takeout options, there's something extra appealing about homemade pizza. Making pizzas in your own kitchen not only allows you to tailor them to your precise specifications, but it can also be a lot of fun — provided that you have the right tools for the job. Designed to help you transfer pizzas into and out of the oven without damaging the cheesy treats or burning your hands, a pizza peel is one such utensil. Pizza paddles are also great for rotating pizzas inside the oven to minimize the risk of any undercooked or charred areas.
Ready to bid farewell to burnt fingers and ruined pizzas? Check out our roundup of the best pizza peels of 2023.
How we selected products
No matter how good your pizza is, all your efforts will be for nothing if your pie ends up on the floor. This is where a quality pizza peel can be a game changer, keeping both you and your pizza out of trouble. Nevertheless, to get the most out of a pizza paddle, you need to first pick one that suits your needs. This is where our help can come in handy.
Our team has spent hours researching the best pizza peels on the market, taking into account both manufacturer specifications and expert and community reviews. During our quest, we looked at a variety of factors. First, we took into account each paddle's material — most pizza shovels are made from aluminum, stainless steel, or wood — and also looked at the size of each gadget's shovel and handle to ensure that it fits both your oven and kitchen. Next, we considered each peel's design — as a rule of thumb, rectangular paddles are better for transfers and round ones are better for rotating food. Lastly, we zeroed in on any additional features, such as foldable handles and extra accessories.
Best overall pizza peel
Available in different sizes and lengths, the New Star Foodservice wooden pizza peel is both sturdy and functional. Made from a single piece of basswood, the peel is lightweight and features a smooth texture that isn't susceptible to cracking. Unlike some other wooden peels, it also doesn't release any oils or come with any rivets. The rustic-style peel features a tapered edge crafted to slide under a pizza and other foods with minimal effort. Plus, it can easily double as a handy serving or cutting board.
The New Star Foodservice wooden pizza peel has received a positive reception on various platforms, including an impressive 9.6 out of 10 on Don't Waste Your Money and 4.6 out of 5 on Amazon. One reviewer praises the pizza paddle, saying, "When your pizza is big and weighted down with pizza toppings, the paddle helps get that pizza onto the hot stone in the oven in an easier transfer. Also, it gets your pizza out and you can cut directly on the board." On the other hand, some shoppers complain the paddle they purchased is overly large, so be sure to order the appropriate peel size when ordering online.
At the time of this writing, you can purchase the New Star Foodservice wooden pizza peel from Amazon starting at $27.97.
Best budget pizza peel
With a price tag of just over $15, the G. a. Homefavor aluminum pizza peel delivers outstanding value for money. Made from aluminum, the 10-inch round slider comes with a triple-riveted wooden handle. Plus, unlike some other pizza paddles, the peel is dishwasher-friendly, making cleaning up after a meal a breeze. And the G. a. Homefavor aluminum pizza peel's 5.5-inch wooden handle comes with a hole for easy storage on a hook or peg.
Despite its affordable price, the G. a. Homefavor aluminum pizza peel has been a hit with Amazon shoppers, receiving an average of 4.7 out of 5 stars from over 800 customers. One buyer says that they bought the peel for transferring frozen pizzas out of the oven, adding, "The metal doesn't bend under the weight at all, and it's easy to clean by hand." Another customer agrees, saying, "The metal is thick enough not to flex much while being thin enough to get under the pizza and not being too heavy." On the downside, some reviewers complain that the paddle's handle is slightly wobbly.
At the time of this writing, you can purchase the G. a. Homefavor aluminum pizza peel from Amazon starting at $15.99.
Best pizza peel for a splurge
The SHANGPEIXUAN turning peel and brush set has been designed to keep your hands away from the scorching heat of an oven. More specifically, the pizza paddle features a 40-inch aluminum handle that stays cool to the touch during use. Also made from aluminum, the utensil's perforated 9-inch paddle is round, making it ideal for both transferring pizzas and turning them in deep ovens. The set also comes with an extra-long oven brush with sturdy brass bristles and a scraper, which can be used to remove hard-to-reach oven grease.
Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars on Amazon, the SHANGPEIXUAN turning peel and brush set has been praised for its sturdiness, non-stick qualities, and ease of assembly. One satisfied shopper says, "I've used it several times and I can say that it works quite well. It's sturdy in your hand, the edge is very smooth, and I've never had a pizza stick to it. Transferring the pizza to my pizza stone is easy and smooth. Cleanup is very easy too."
At the time of this writing, you can purchase the SHANGPEIXUAN turning peel and brush set from Amazon starting at $69.99.
Best adjustable pizza peel
The Q's INN large pizza peel features three different handle length options including 11.8, 19.7, and 31.5 inches, making the gadget ideal for both deep and shallow ovens — simply use the shorter or longer handle or combine the two. The longer wooden handle piece can also be used to roll out pizza dough. And at the end of the day, the peel can be disassembled for easy storage. Last but not least, the rounded blade is made from non-stick aluminum to ensure ease of use and durability.
The Q's INN large pizza peel has garnered positive reviews from Amazon customers, receiving an average of 4.6 out of 5 stars from nearly 1,000 reviewers. One shopper applauds the pizza peel, saying, "[The] paddle is pretty legit. Nice size, sturdy, and easy to clean. The adjustable handle is a nice touch, too." Another buyer concurs, saying that the peel is "well made and [the] perfect length." On the flip side, some shoppers say that the thread on the handle is too fine, making it slightly tricky to assemble.
At the time of this writing, you can purchase the Q's INN large pizza peel from Amazon starting at $42.97.
Best pizza peel and stone combo
Suitable for ovens and barbecues, the Hans Grill pizza peel and stone set has everything you need to get started making delicious homemade pizzas. The rectangular cordierite baking stone helps transfer heat and absorb any excess moisture from the pizza dough to ensure a better textured pizza and crispier crust. Meanwhile, the wooden paddle is perfect for sliding your pizza into and out of the oven.
Overall, the Hans Grill pizza peel and stone set has received favorable ratings on different platforms including 9.1 out of 10 on Best Views Reviews and 9 out of 10 on Don't Waste Your Money. Robert Parsons from Pizza Oven Reviews gives the bundle 4.7 out of 5 stars, saying that it makes a nice set for beginner pizza makers. Parsons also highlights that while on the small side, the pizza peel does support the weight of the pizza dough and toppings. Amazon shoppers have awarded the Hans Grill pizza paddle and stone set 4.4 out of 5 stars, with 69% of buyers giving it 5 out of 5 stars. While many reviewers are happy that the bundle comes with a pizza peel, some do point out that the peel is too small in comparison to the size of the pizza stone.
At the time of this writing, you can purchase the Hans Grill pizza peel and stone set from Amazon starting at $39.99.
Best pizza peel with a long handle
Measuring 64 inches, the American Metalcraft medium blade peel is one of the longest pizza shovels on the market. And while the slider may be too lengthy for standard ovens, it's perfect for deep commercial-style baking ovens. Combining a thin aluminum paddle and a smooth triple-riveted wooden handle, the pizza shovel is easy to slide under food items and maneuver. Plus, it's perfect for making an impression on guests when you use it to deliver pizza from the oven right to the dining table.
The American Metalcraft medium blade peel has been praised by Amazon shoppers, who have awarded it an average of 4.7 out of 5 stars. One customer says the peel is a great value, adding, "In a world where pizza making supplies cost an arm and a leg, it's nice to know that this peel exists. It feels good in the hand and is well built ... I even use this to rotate my pizzas in place of a round turning peel, and it works great ... it's still going strong after over 700 pizzas." This being said, some reviewers point out that the spatula's wooden handle comes with a mediocre finish and that the utensil can be tricky to store due to its size.
At the time of this writing, you can purchase the American Metalcraft medium blade peel from Amazon starting at $44.80.
Best perforated pizza peel
Pizza peels have perforations for a number of reasons. For starters, perforations minimize sticking, making the pizza easier to slide off the paddle. They also help to remove any excess flour that could burn and affect the taste of the food. Lastly, perforations help to release moisture, preventing your pizza from becoming soggy.
If you're after a perforated pizza peel with a short handle, the Ooni perforated pizza peel is one of the best on the market. Crafted from aluminum, the rectangular paddle comes with a tapered edge and is lightweight enough for easy transfers of food into and out of the oven. Meanwhile, the handle is made from heat-resistant, glass-reinforced nylon. The Ooni perforated pizza peel is available in either 12- or 14-inch sizes.
Offering testament to its high quality and ease of use, Pizza Oven Reviews rates the Ooni perforated pizza peel 5 out of 5. According to the platform, the paddle is non-stick and performs well, even with pizzas loaded with toppings. Amazon shoppers seem to agree, awarding the gadget 4.7 out of 5 stars. One customer says the peel "works like a charm," adding, "It is thin and easily gets under the cooked pizza to pull it out. Have never had a pizza stick to the peel either."
At the time of this writing, you can purchase the ooni perforated pizza peel from Amazon starting at $59.99.
Best pizza peel for turning pizza
Pairing a round 9-inch pizza shovel with an adjustable wooden handle, the Chef Pomodoro aluminum pizza peel is ideal for rotating food in the oven to ensure even baking and prevent sticking. The wooden handle can be tailored to measure either 26.8 or 47 inches and disassembles for easy storage. Meanwhile, the 9-inch hard anodized aluminum paddle features perforations and a tapered edge that makes it easy to slide under food.
The Chef Pomodoro aluminum pizza peel has received the thumbs up from more than 700 Amazon shoppers who have rated it 4.7 out of 5 stars. One reviewer recommends the gadget, saying it's "versatile, easy to clean, and looks great! It's a really good tool to have if you have a home pizza oven. It's also a great price compared to similar items available." Unfortunately, some customers complain that the peel's handle comes apart at connection points
At the time of this writing, you can purchase the Chef Pomodoro aluminum pizza peel from Amazon starting at $39.99.
Best innovative pizza peel
Pairing a wooden pizza paddle and a pastry cloth, the Super Peel pro composite pizza transfer peel works just like a conveyor belt. Ideal for beginners, the paddle makes sliding pizzas into and out of the oven a breeze. Plus, it's non-stick and can be popped into the dishwasher for easy cleaning. The pizza peel can also be used without the cotton cloth if you prefer traditional-style pizza paddles. And the Super Peel pro composite pizza transfer peel is made in the U.S., so you can feel good knowing that you're supporting American manufacturing.
The Super Peel pro composite pizza transfer peel has received many favorable reviews from Amazon customers who appreciate the gadget's effectiveness and ease of use. One satisfied shopper recommends the pizza peel to both novices and pros, elaborating, "The design prevents accidental dough rips, and I haven't had any pizza casualties in my small home kitchen since using it. The removable cloth easily gets clean in the washing machine." Another reviewer calls the peel perfection, adding, "This thing is amazing. Pizza slides off and onto my baking steel perfectly, smooth as butter! I feel like a pro using this thing."
At the time of this writing, you can purchase the Super Peel pro composite pizza transfer peel from Amazon starting at $67.95.
Best foldable pizza peel
Limited kitchen space can be a nuisance, with large appliances only exacerbating the problem. This is where collapsible utensils can come in handy. Easy to store and transport, the Chef Pomodoro pizza peel with a foldable handle collapses down to just 14 inches from its full length, which measures 24 inches. Made from high-quality aluminum, the paddle comes with a pine wood handle to ensure a comfortable grip.
The Chef Pomodoro pizza peel with a foldable handle has received favorable reviews on numerous platforms, including 9.6 out of 10 on Best Views Reviews and 9.4 out of 10 on Don't Waste Your Money. The pizza paddle has also been awarded 4.6 out of 5 stars from more than 4,500 Amazon shoppers. One happy buyer says that they are very pleased with the peel, elaborating, "I like that it's easy to clean and not a big deal to loosen the screw and fold the handle around for easy storage. So far it's working great!" On the downside, some customers say that the screws on the paddle's handle can be hard to tighten.
At the time of this writing, you can purchase the Chef Pomodoro pizza peel with a foldable handle from Amazon starting at $29.99.
Best pizza peel set
The jcaeh pizza peel set has all your baking needs covered. Aside from a foldable pizza paddle, the 7-piece set is bundled with two pizza pans (one of which is perforated), a rocker cutter, an oven mitt, a baking brush, and a triangular pizza slice server. Made from high-quality aluminum, the paddle comes with a wooden handle complete with a hanging loop for easy storage. Meanwhile, the pizza pans are crafted from carbon steel, and the pizza cutter and server are made from stainless steel.
The jcaeh pizza peel set has received 4.6 out of 5 stars from more than 300 Amazon shoppers, with 71% of reviewers awarding it 5 out of 5 stars. One buyer says the set is a great value, adding, "You get a lot of stuff for 30 bucks and it all is decent quality. The rocker knife is especially useful and way better than a pizza wheel. And the pizza peel is very nice. Love the wooden handle!" Another customer reiterates this sentiment, saying, "There's actually quit a bit of items you are getting for a low price, and it's all good quality!"
At the time of this writing, you can purchase the jcaeh pizza peel set from Amazon starting at $30.