17 Popular Mustards, Ranked Worst To Best

Daily Chef is a brand that is a part of Member's Mark, which is owned by Sam's Club. While the warehouse club store is well known for several delectable treats from their own brands, this organic yellow mustard falls flat.

There are no strange ingredients used; all are within the scope of a regular yellow mustard recipe such as spices like paprika and turmeric. However, reviewer Wizhat2 gave it a one-star rating. They claim to have tried various mustards before, including generic, and have concluded that this one has an "odd flavor."

But Sam's Club itself isn't a write-off when it comes to purchasing large quantities of mustard. Consumers can purchase other name brands in large two-pack bottles, a jug that weighs over 6 pounds, and a 500-count box of individual packets. Even if you have room left over in one of their oversized shopping carts, this mustard can be left on one of the seemingly endless store shelves.

Spicy brown mustard gets its bite by soaking the mustard seeds in less vinegar during the preparation process. This means that the mustard seeds (brown and black, normally) are truer to their original taste. A variety of spices, such as cinnamon or nutmeg, can be used for a more robust flavor, but that doesn't seem to be the case for the Target-brand Market Pantry spicy brown mustard which falls short in the taste department.

The mustard is labeled as "zesty deli style," which is another way to indicate the rich spiciness. None of the standard ingredients stand out that would lead one to believe this has an off taste, though one addition is simply labelled as "spices" which is obviously quite vague. Onion powder is another ingredient that might raise an eyebrow, but it still doesn't pinpoint whatever the exact problem is. According to a reviewer on Target's website, the "flavor is too harsh" and it tasted more like horseradish. Another notes that it's "nothing special." Have no fear, there are other spicy brown varieties on this list that stay true to the traditional zing.

Aldi is a unique grocery store that began in Germany and has since spread worldwide. It first came here in 1976  and now has a dedicated Stateside following. Fans appreciate the chain's low prices for staple foods like meats, breads, and frozen items. You won't normally find too many name-brand products on their shelves, as Aldi's inventory is stocked with over 90% of their own private brands such as Burman's which specializes in condiments.

Their spicy brown mustard currently costs only $0.99, according to Instacart. It's made with the usual distilled vinegar, mustard seeds, and spices found in any regular mustard, so what could be so wrong? Actually, not much. As far as discount mustards go, Aldi's Burman's brand isn't too bad. Fooducate gives it an "A" rating, but watch out for 80 milligrams of sodium, which is slightly higher per serving (one teaspoon) compared to other brands. For that reason, we placed this in the middle of our list.  

When you think about baseball, you probably imagine a stifling hot summer day spent at a packed stadium, rooting for your favorite team. Perhaps you indulge in an ice cream cone to cool off, or dig into popular ballpark fare, like hot dogs. That's where a quality mustard is needed and Bertman Original Ball Park Mustard has you, or rather, your hot dog covered.

Since 1925, Bertman has manufactured their brown mustard out of Cleveland, Ohio and it has become not just a staple there, but at arenas and stadiums across the United States. In a head-to-head taste test with the other most famous ball park mustard, Stadium Mustard, Bertman's Original just narrowly takes top billing.

Whether you're into baseball or not, this official mustard of the Cleveland Guardians is sure to please. It is so good that Amazon reviewer Jay. L. claims they threw their yellow mustard in the garbage after having Bertman's. Another consumer review, by Long John Sliver, suggests that this mustard is great on both grilled meats and cold cuts.

Great Value is the Walmart generic brand name. They have pretty much every kind of product you can think of, including home goods, toiletries, cleaning supplies, and groceries. Their foods are hit-or-miss, meaning that sometimes one of their generic products is tasty but other times it might be better to spend a little extra for the name brand and the quality that comes with it. That being said, one Great Value food product you should consider trying is their yellow mustard.

Yes, seriously! According to Walmart's website, there's nothing abnormal within the ingredients — mustard seed, vinegar, water, and some spices. There are zero calories and 60 milligrams of sodium per teaspoon, which is standard when it comes to the tangy condiment. Plus, a 20-ounce bottle will set you back a mere dollar. Now that's a deal!

Reviewer Marbelva claims that Great Value yellow mustard is "as good as French's." Over on Influenster, the reviews are also positive with Teresa G. suggesting it has the "same taste as name brands." All in all, don't devalue Great Value, at least when it comes to mustard.

Self-described as "creamy and zesty," Plochman's Kosciusko spicy brown mustard is a classic and refined take on an age-old, simple condiment. It is an award winning mustard from a company that's been in business for more than 150 years in the United States. The brand Kosciusko joined Plochman's in the 1980s and brought their spicy brown mustard with them, bottling it in their iconic barrel-shaped container. Since then, they've introduced dozens of mustard blends, including Carolina BBQ, Champagne, Bourbon, and even Balsamic. They even have new mustard mixers in various flavors like Roasted Garlic and Sweet Thai Chili.

While a 9-ounce bottle will set you back $6.99 on Amazon, reviewers hint that it's well worth it. Consumer T. Baker recommends that this mustard is the closest thing to an "East Coast deli" taste and has a nicely smooth texture that is "not gritty." Gary -Florida compares it favorably to spicy brown mustards from Germany, and notes that it "enhances the flavor of anything it's put on."

Sir Kensington's is a company you can trust. They are a Certified B Corporation, which recognizes high performance standards in regards to societal impact, environmental sustainability, communicative transparency, and legal responsibility. Their business goal is to have a positive effect on the globe while providing quality, gourmet products to their customers. Those items include an extensive lineup of condiments include customer favorites such as mayonnaise, ketchup, dressings, sauces, and of course mustard.

Their award-winning mustard comes in several varieties, but it's their coarse, spicy brown that shines. Using top grade mustard seeds and a touch of Vermont maple syrup to balance out the tangy bite, this spicy brown is unlike any other. It's also vegan. You'll have to give up 10 calories per teaspoon, but why wouldn't you? One Amazon reviewer, who calls themselves states it perfectly: You will feel like a royal eating this mustard. Another reviewer, May, writes the only con is that they don't have a Sir Kensington's mustard factory in their backyard.

Heinz is a beloved homegrown condiment company that dates back to 1869. Most famous for their tomato ketchup, they've grown into a world-leader in condiments ranging from pickles, mayonnaise, gravy, vinegar, and most recently a line of unique mixed sauces. When it comes to basic mustard, Heinz 100% natural yellow mustard is one of the very best. It's a classic! Made with all natural ingredients, the strikingly bright yellow condiment provides a burst of zesty zing to your favorite meats, sandwiches, and sauces. And the best part? Zero calories, zero sugar, and zero sodium.

Influenster reviews are overwhelmingly positive with a near perfect rating based on over 900 reviews. It's also listed as their second choice of mustards overall. Consumer Maika R. writes that this mustard matches the high quality that one would expect from Heinz food products. Melissa C. claims that "you can not go wrong" with Heinz's yellow mustard, especially for the affordable price.

Mustard in its natural form is derived from the mustard seed, which can be beneficial for your health. However, in processed condiment form, it's French's Classic Yellow that is the most beneficial on burgers and hot dogs. And classic it is, ever since French's debuted at the 1904 World's Fair. It quickly became an American favorite, whether you were at a baseball game or a local backyard barbecue. Although they provide a plethora of condiments and other food products including Crispy Fried Onions and chili seasonings, the name French's has become synonymous with yellow mustard.

It holds a steady 4.9 out of 5-rating with 97% of reviewers recommending the bright yellow product, via McCormick's website. Influenster ranks it as their top mustard (with over 7,000 consumer reviews) and rightfully so. Ginger L. suggests adding it to chicken and egg salads, and praises the top quality for the value. Erin H. calls it the "best yellow mustard out there" and contends that it's the only one to buy, claiming that it tastes better than store-branded varieties. They also rave that the consistency is just right and the squeeze bottle provides the perfect portion, along with the ideal tang, of course. French's mustard just can't be beat.